This
monograph has its origins in lectures presented to political science
students at the University of Durban-Westville, as well as to officers
on the Joint Staff Course at the Defence Force College in Pretoria.
Students expressed their concern about the `First World` and Eurocentric
bias of much of the available literature on new security thinking.
Officers, on the other hand, displayed scepticism as to the practical
utility of new security thinking. What this publication attempts to do,
then, is to critically analyse new security thinking through the lens of
Southern Africa and Africa. In addition, it seeks to explore the
interface between theory and practice, thereby hoping to lay to rest any
scepticism on the practical utility of the new security agenda.
In the first article, Hussein Solomon examines the historical
development of new security thinking, assesses the criticism levelled
against it and analyses its impact on policy. In his penetrating
rejoinder, Anton du Plessis questions the `newness` of new security
thinking and stresses that a synthesis of exogenous and indigenous
thinking must be developed in response to local security imperatives.
Heidi Hudson`s superbly researched A Feminist Reading of Security in Africa not
only offers an alternative vision of security in Africa through the
lens of gender, but also presents an inclusive vision of global security
representative of the rich tapestry of experiences of both men and
women. In her response, Virginia Gamba emphasises the fact that feminist
thought never existed in isolation from the mainstream of security
thinking, and that women have made a fundamental impact on the changing
character of security concerns world-wide. Gamba also notes that, in
many societies, religion and culture often legitimise structures of male
supremacy.
It is hoped that Maxi van Aardt`s excellent The Application of the New Security Agenda for Southern Africa will
stimulate the debate between academics and practitioners, especially
since she raises some pertinent questions, such as the implications of
the apparent `retreat` of military security for creating and maintaining
broad security. In her incisive rejoinder, Marie Muller notes how
globalisation is impacting on political thinking and convincingly argues
for an integrated approach to security and development.