Monograph 10: Conflict Management, Peacekeeping and Peacebuilding: Lessons for Africa from a Seminar Past, Edited by Mark Malan

This monograph is based on an edited selection of papers presented
at Exercise Morning Star, which was conducted at the South African Army
College, Pretoria from 9 to 20 September 1996. Morning Star consisted of
a five-day seminar and a five-day map exercise, which were designed to
provide senior officers of the South African National Defence Force
(SANDF), as well as invited participants from civil society and the
armed forces of other Southern African Development Community (SADC)
countries, with a theoretical and practical orientation towards the
doctrine, planning, and command and control of peace support operations
at the strategic, operational and tactical levels. The SANDF enlisted
the assistance of the Institute for Security Studies (ISS), a
non-government research institute which focuses on security studies, in
the planning and conduct of this high-level training seminar. The
significance of the latter lies in the fact that expertise related to
conflict management, peacekeeping and peacebuilding is no longer
regarded as a purely, or even predominantly, military domain. Although
this has been recognised for some time in the more developed world, the
emergence of new partnerships for the pursuit of peace in Africa is a
development which should be nurtured, if it is to grow into an effective
instrument for appropriate action.
The aim of this monograph is less ambitious, but similar to that
of Morning Star, namely to provide a general overview of the
interrelated issues of conflict management, peacekeeping and
peacebuilding, about which every concerned soldier and citizen of Africa
should be informed. The first chapter provides a brief geopolitical
survey of the state of conflict in Africa. Seen through the eyes of
Elisha Muzonzini, Africa is a continent which is steeped in conflict,
the sources of which are both diverse and endemic, and include military
intervention in national politics, ethno-political rivalry,
under-development, and poor governance. Indeed, the nature and scope of
conflict in Africa has reached a point where the international community
has become increasingly wary of intervention in Africa in order to
attempt to resolve or manage violent conflicts on the continent.
It is now widely accepted that African leaders in general, and
the Organisation of African Unity in particular, must accept an
increased burden of responsibility for managing conflict in Africa. Like
the United Nations, the OAU`s capacity to achieve success in this area
is determined, in the final analysis, by the individual and collective
political will of its member states to do so. Nevertheless, far less is
generally known about the structure, role and functions of the OAU, than
is the case with the UN. In the second chapter, Cedric de Coning
provides a concise, but clear overview of the role of the OAU in
conflict management in Africa. Given the limited resources available to
this regional body, and the fact that the ultimate responsibility for
the maintenance of international peace and security remains firmly with
the UN, the OAU may never assume total responsibility for conflict
management between and within its member states. The OAU has therefore
concentrated its efforts in the realm of preventive diplomacy, mediation
and observation, leaving the task of conducting more resource intensive
peace operations largely to the world body.
However, the recent experiences of the UN in the conduct of peace
operations in countries such as Mozambique and Angola, and especially
Rwanda and Somalia, have indicated that a UN peace operation provides no
panacea for sustainable peace and development in African countries
afflicted by the scourge of internal conflict. In the third chapter,
Peter Voetmann provides a realistic appraisal of the scope and limits of
such intervention by explaining the structure, planning and execution
of UN peace operations. Voetmann`s contribution is followed by a more
explicit exposition of some lessons learned during peacekeeping
operations in Africa. Henry Anyidoho reiterates a number of points made
by Muzonzini, De Coning and Voetmann, within the context of past UN
missions and the ongoing subregional operation in Liberia conducted by
the Economic Community of West African States Monitoring Group (ECOMOG).
He also raises several of the issues which are dealt with in more
detail in the remaining chapters of the monograph, such as the
relationships between peacekeepers and the media, and that between
peacekeepers and the various UN agencies involved in saving lives in
Africa.
Indeed, the importance of communication within peace operations
is often underestimated, or referred to merely in passing. In the fifth
chapter, David Wimhurst provides an insightful perspective on the
importance of communication to the success of a peace operation.
Wimhurst does not refer to the problems of communication between
multinational and multilingual troop contingents and the host
population, but to the broader relevance of appropriate communication to
sustain a fragile peace process which is being guided and monitored by a
peacekeeping mission. His anecdotal arguments, based on personal
experience as spokesperson for the third UN Operation in Mozambique
(UNAVEM III), provide a number of pertinent lessons on how information
can be used to sustain and protect the peace process.
In the sixth chapter, Miguel de Brito has drawn on the
experiences of the UN operation in Mozambique (ONUMOZ) to provide an
informed analysis of the relationships between peacekeepers, host
governments and local populations. Even where multifunctional
peacekeeping in Africa has widely been regarded as a success, such as
the UN mission in Mozambique, De Brito argues that the sensitivities of
both the host government and the local population must be understood and
respected by the peacekeepers. Failure to do so not only threatens the
execution of the mission, but can also create resentment and adverse
social effects in the longer term, beyond the termination of the peace
operation.
In the final chapter, David Whaley and Barbara Piazza-Georgi also
express concern about the longer term effects of peace operations in
their discussion of the linkage between peacekeeping and peacebuilding.
The problems of development and socio economic reconstruction, or
post-conflict peacebuilding are more enduring than those related to the
supervision of a peace process which leads to adherence to the carefully
circumscribed terms of a peace accord, the staging of elections, and
the withdrawal of the peacekeepers. Whaley and Piazza-Georgi argue that
the concept and practice of peacekeeping should not contradict or
aggravate the process of post conflict peacebuilding, and that there
should be a clear and positive linkage between the two processes from
the inception of a peace operation. Development, after all, is the most
enduring challenge facing the African continent. It is widely regarded
as the underlying solution to all Africa`s woes, just as lack thereof is
identified as a major cause of continued conflict and turmoil.
Collectively, the contributors provide a brief, but broad
orientation on the challenges of conflict management, peacekeeping and
peacebuilding. The subject matter ranges from the general to the more
specific and, while perhaps not providing definitive answers to Africa`s
problems, certainly serves to foster an understanding of how these have
been managed, and may be better managed in future.